Because there is so much sugar in relish & chutney

from the supermarket I wondered if I could make one using stevia, anyone done this?

Chef_white_elephant, Mar 11, 7:38 pm

haven't done it. but it is possible.

why is there so much sugar - it is a preserving agent

Chef_duckmoon, Mar 11, 8:21 pm

I saw one the other day calling for stevia n honey as the sweetners so google is your friend.

Chef_shan4, Mar 11, 10:43 pm

If you are going to the trouble to make your own then just use less sugar than in the recipe rather than fiddling around with non-nutritive sweeteners. Over the years of low sugar diet I have found that out of all sweeteners, sugar is still the best. I just try to use much less. Sugar is not the only preservative in chutneys, etc, vinegar is as well.

I do agree with you about how sweet processed pickles, etc are. Once, when served something with one of those preparations on, I wondered if if a mistake had been made and jam had been used. Blerk.

Chef_buzzy110, Mar 12, 8:46 am

if you follow buzzy approach. I would do two other things
1. be more pedantic than usual in sterilizing jars and
2. assume that it will not keep very long

Chef_duckmoon, Mar 12, 7:22 pm

I made a Sweet and Sour Gherkin relish last summer and replaced sugar with liquid sweetener (just stirred it through at end of cooking time). I kept the jars in fridge, but in saying that I dont know how long they would have stayed edible as they disappeared too fast.

Chef_baalamb, Mar 12, 7:58 pm

One has to wonder how many spoonfulls of relish one needs on the plate for a sugar overload

Chef_illusion_, Mar 13, 10:16 pm

I'm no expert but i have been making my own relishes / jams ect for probably 15 years. I have tried using less sugar and it just doesn't work that well, like duckmoon said above, it wont keep the same.

Chef_holly-rocks, Mar 14, 3:07 pm

For me at least, it isn't a matter of sugar overload. It is a matter of taste. Having a sickly sweet (once again to my palate) on a savoury food is just horrible and ruins the dish. And as I mentioned it is sometimes hard to decide if it is a jam or a relish.

That is one of the reasons prefer fermented condiments. No sugar at all.

Chef_buzzy110, Mar 14, 3:38 pm

Yes, sugar and vinegar are preserving agents. Helps things 'keep' for years. So if you change the balances, you end up with something that has a short use by and needs to be kept in the fridge.

Chef_deanna14, Mar 14, 3:39 pm

you can replace some of the vinegar with water as long as you keep it in the fridge and in that was use less sugar . alison hoilst used to use almost no sugar and some thing i cant remember so bring her pickles up and see if you can find it

Chef_whitehead., Mar 14, 6:25 pm

I had the same thought. Relish and chutney are condiments, right?

Chef_hestia, Dec 28, 2:53 pm

Share this thread