Weird but yummy sandwich fillings

Of course, the yummy part is rather subjective.

My fave is sliced tomato on peanut butter. There is something delish about the acid in the tomato with the creaminess of the peanut butter

Chef_roshu, Jun 13, 3:41 pm

People think my cheese sammies are weird - cheese, marmite, tomato sauce and mayo. I think they're yum!

Salmon (tinned), marmite and tomato relish. YUM again!

Marmite and banana.

Hmmmm there seems to be a theme with my weirdness.

Chef_kirmag, Jun 13, 3:51 pm

Marmite and potato chips (green onion)

Chef_asue, Jun 13, 4:29 pm

Cheese and raspberry jam
Banana and raspberry jam
Banana and salt
Tomato and sugar
Yes, I am on the hefty side! ha

Chef_dwyn5, Jun 13, 4:34 pm

celery and peanut butter
celery and cheese and marmite

Chef_gardner8, Jun 13, 4:37 pm

Crunchy peanut butter and bacon in Vogels.

Chef_karenz, Jun 13, 5:04 pm

marmite and fresh fennel

Chef_..james.., Jun 13, 6:05 pm

Potato chips and vegemite. Chocolate chips.

Chef_karenz, Jun 13, 6:10 pm

Chippies and marmite/vegemite!

Chef_attabiah, Jun 13, 6:12 pm


Definitely a theme . how did you cope when the common denominator was out of production?
Stock pile?

Chef_samanya, Jun 13, 6:16 pm

My mum used to make Marmite and walnut sandwiches - the walnut was chopped very finely. Keeping with the Marmite theme, I also like Marmite and sliced cold, cooked potato. My daughter's favourite sandwich is corn chips, spaghetti and tomato!

Chef_carlos57, Jun 13, 7:12 pm

I remember in teenage years eating Peanut butter and beetroot sandwhiches, freshly made not soggy they were yum

Chef_karlymouse, Jun 13, 7:30 pm

Kiwifruit (very thinly sliced) cheese slice and ham

Chef_jascas, Jun 13, 7:42 pm

Kiwifruit and cream cheese is yummy.
Peanut butter, cheese slice and banana (or any combo of the 3)

Chef_dibble35, Jun 13, 7:51 pm



Num num! That sounds pretty good! Actually a few walnuts added would be pretty good too :D

Chef_holly-rocks, Jun 13, 8:10 pm

My son, now aged 37, from a very young age, loved and still loves, vegemite and honey! .
I enjoy dates and walnuts. yummy.

Chef_elsielaurie1, Jun 13, 8:42 pm

Not so weird but def yummy; Banana with a good layer of coconut and a sprinkle of cinnamon. Mash the banana slightly so the coconut sticks better.
Also great as a toasted sandwich with a side of cream or icecream!

Chef_bella95, Jun 14, 1:44 am

My nan loves thinly sliced watermelon in hers. Last night hubby did boiled egg n chicken chips - yum. We also like cream cheese and drained tinned apricots. Plus the norm, vegemite or marmite n chips ( sons fave).

Chef_ursula4, Jun 14, 6:16 am

I love Beetroot and cheese toasted sandwiches.

Chef_molly37, Jun 14, 6:55 am



Hahahaha yes I had a secret stash for when the need would arise.

Chef_kirmag, Jun 14, 8:07 am


Good on you!
Bet plenty wished they has stashed, as well.

Chef_samanya, Jun 14, 11:04 am

A friend of mine makes cream cheese and strawberry sandwiches, the are really lovely.

Chef_chris313, Jun 14, 1:09 pm

crunchie peanut butter, tomato and mung bean

vegemite and walnuts

apricot jam and cheese

Chef_mica3, Jun 14, 1:53 pm

Not in a sandwich but other bizarre things that taste great together is that at the movies we dip our icecreams into the popcorn, fabulous popcorn on aa stick, think it must be to do with the salt and icecream thing cause I used to dip french fries into icecream sundaes, also very yummy but I haave moved on somewhat! lol

Chef_hunter246, Jun 14, 3:58 pm

Marmite and honey. My grandmother introduced me to this 50+ years ago. She used to have it on Sao crackers.

Chef_maximus44, Jun 14, 6:55 pm

I love toasted pita bread, sliced open with crunchy peanut butter, sweet chilli sauce and black olives. Yum :-)

Chef_scarlettnz, Jun 14, 7:05 pm

A fav from Elvis; peanut butter, banana & mayonnaise.

Chef_threecheers, Jun 14, 8:09 pm

I love radishes and salt. I've never found anyone except my Mum who liked this

Chef_cottagerose, Jun 14, 9:05 pm

Bacon & fried onion - not weird, but tasty.
Bacon mushroom and cream cheese or sour cream, baguette - ditto.

Chef_socram, Jun 16, 5:27 pm

count me in that's all time fave of mine, if I can get them in the sammie before I eat them all, I also adore cress sammies
as a kid it was pouring cream over jam on the bread
luncheon or cold sausages with coleslaw or tom sauce
date sammies
marmite and chips
I rarely eat them now as most of these I loved on white bread which I rarely ever eat now

Chef_motorbo, Jun 16, 5:38 pm

Not weird just some of our favs
Chicken, cream cheese and apricot
Satay chicken and salad
Shaved ham, mustard and cole slaw
Sweet ones
Cream cheese, chopped dates/apricots and chopped crystalised ginger. Also good with chopped walnuts added.
Marmite, banana and honey

Chef_nauru, Jun 16, 8:11 pm

club sandwich with cream cheese, pineapple, ham and spring onion . mmmmmmmmmm

Chef_purplegoanna, Jun 16, 10:20 pm

Radish and salt! That's the only way to eat them isn't it? Yum!
Vegemite/marmite and lettuce. I'm surprised no one else has mentioned that one! Maybe it's a south island thing?

Chef_nik12, Jun 17, 12:08 am

Oh yes lettuce and marmite! Southern belles I guess.

Chef_chainedgypsy, Jun 17, 9:53 am

Love chippies on crusty bread . yummmm

Chef_figjamto, Jun 17, 11:08 am

peanut butter and shredded cabbage, with a peeled small carrot on the side.
Beetroot, cheese and hummus,
sprouts on top of anything except for jam,
mint leaves and peanut butter

Chef_redders01, Jun 17, 4:43 pm

i also love this combo, and marmite and marmalade

Chef_sevenge, Jun 17, 5:19 pm

marmite cheese and lettuce,
chesse and tomato sauce
stuffing+gravy from roast chicken

honey and chesse

Chef_quarterpasttwo, Jun 17, 6:02 pm



I do! When I was growing up, salted sliced radishes, layered between mum's buttered bread was a favourite. I haven't had them for years. I must do so again. I loved the peppery taste of crisp and crunchy radishes with butter and home made bread. Thanks for the memory cottagerose.

Chef_lurtz, Jun 17, 8:21 pm

oh no as a kid I loved lettuce/marmite and cheese

or cheese marmite and beetroot

Chef_motorbo, Jun 17, 10:01 pm

sandwhich with cream cheese then tinned salmon (once crushed) and a piece of asparagus,then roll it up YUMMMM

Chef_zsiska76, Jun 17, 10:14 pm

i like chicken chips and avocado sandwiches not that that happens often

and when i was a kid i was always jelous of other kids luncheon and tomato sauce sandwiches but mum wouldnt make me one lol, wouldnt want 1 now tho :P

Chef_lucky1989, Jun 18, 9:58 am

I love tomato and sugar
Lettuce marmite and raw onion
Luncheon sour cream and tomato sauce
Peanut butter and apple

Chef_jstlookin4bargn, Jun 18, 3:48 pm

Not a sandwich, but I like:

Slice apple on toast ( toast buttered of course (.

Chef_willman, Jun 18, 6:12 pm



I like banana on toast with a little drizzle of honey

Chef_nauru, Jun 18, 7:06 pm

love lettuce and marmite!

and walnuts, raisins and cottage cheese

oohh and tomatos on sugar buns omg

Chef_southerngurl, Jun 18, 7:51 pm

Lettuce & vegemite.
Banana & potato chips.
Banana & peanut butter (prefer crunchy, not smooth).

Plus my mums special; sliced mutton, lettuce and her homemade salad dressing. Out of this world!

Chef_reklaw2, Jun 18, 8:05 pm

Tamarillo and sugar

Chef_kaddiew, May 20, 3:16 pm

Share this thread